Ko Mwari kutsivana ano murume Western?

Muna nharo, sezvo tichiziva, chokwadi anoberekwa. Nepo kwete nguva pazvose yeRoma Katurike pamusoro pfungwa uye mashoko evanhu vari dzokuMadokero munzanga European vaiva vaikurukura kana Mwari ariko. Kubvira pamazuva Greece yekare akagadzira chikuru uchapupu kune yepamusoro simba. Izvi dzisiri uye musoro. Sezvingatarisirwa, vakanga zvakataurwa vazivi kwete kuratidza kuvapo Zeusi kana Osiris, asi rinoratidza kuvapo imwe nyika uye, Chikurukuru, mumwe Musiki wezvinhu zvose wedu yatiri kurarama.

Sezvo tinogona kuona, kubva pakutanga chaipo nevafungi avo musoro Masvomhu pamusoro kana Mwari ariko, takaenda zvishoma nenzira isiri. Zvikonzero zvavo vakanga inobva axiom hakusi chaizvo pachena kuti kana umwe upenyu huripo, zvichaita vaizongoguma kuva murongi nomusiki ichi. Most zvitendero zvenyika hunogara nezvokuti pane "Musiki wezvinhu zvose, zvinoonekwa nyika asingaoneki." Asi kana mumwe munhu akavaka imba, kubva ichi hazvirevi kuti iye akamutswa uye zvachose zvakasiyana marongerwo. Zvikurukuru kubvira mamiriro wechipiri yakaratidza zhinji "mapurani zvaunokanganisa."

Kusakwana zvinhu nyika iri pachena kuti aiona zvakakwana akanyatsokodzerwa. Saka vaya vari kuedza kuratidza kuti Mwari ariko, kunotozongoita akatarisana nechinetso theodicy, ndiko kuti, kuna pembedzo Musiki nokuda nouipi. Rinozivikanwa nyanzvi kuMiddle Ages, Thomas Aquinas yakatanga shanu chikuru uchapupu ari pamusoro yepamusoro uchenjeri uye vakapa maonero avo pamusoro sei upenyu zvakaipa. Sezvo Mwari ane zvakanaka zvose (ane kuvapo kunoratidzwa kuburikidza shanu tichishandisa simba okuti nomufungo zvikonzero vakapiwa Aquinas) anoda kubatsira nesimba munyika. Zvisinei, zvakasikwa anosiiwa kuMusiki, naizvozvo, hazvina kukwana. Pane chiedza, pane mumvuri (kunyange mumvuri chaizvoizvo pave chinhu kuti absorbs vanopenya simba). Apo pane utano, panewo chirwere (kunyange kusimba chinyorwa, sezvo chirwere anoonekwa somunhu "kusava utano" pane chirwere chaiko).

Mhedziso "Summa Theologica 'Aquinas, tichiedza kupa dzoga mhinduro yomubvunzo wokuti kana Mwari ariko, vakaputsa muzivi wokuGermany Immanuel Kant. Uchapupu ariko iye munyika, hazvifaniri kwakavakirwa mitemo kwomuitirowo zvisingarambiki. Pachirehwa chete kutsanangura chikonzero-uye-chaizvoizvo ukama pakati zvinhu zvinhu. Uye zvirokwazvo, sezvo nokukurumidza kuuya nguva apo kutsoropodzwa yezvouMwari zvekungofungira yeRoma Katurike haana kunobatanidza zvinorwadza chirango nomoto, akanzwa kukakavara uye «contra».

Vadadi haana stint pamusoro rakajeka mifananidzo. Somuenzaniso, imwe ethologist Richard Dawkins mubasa rake kuna illusory hunhu kwokutenda, achitsvaka kuratidza kuti Mwari haako, saka pakushora uchapupu, "maererano mwero pakukwana." Ngatitii mumwe munhu anoti kana tinoona vamwe dzakapfirirwa zvinhu, tinogona kufungidzira kupfuura akakwana unhu Zvivako zviri risinganyepi uye zvose zvakanaka hwakanaka. "Zvisinei, tiri kuona kuti vanhu exude Rinofembedza siyana. Naizvozvo, panofanira kuva mukuru kune vose Rinofembedza ose skunk, panodamwa Mwari .... "

All mibvunzo Kereke achiedza kumanikidza kutenda zvose-Zvakanaka musiki zvinhu zvenyika, vari deadlocked. Masayendisiti dzakaratidza kuti zvinokonzera zvakasikwa aiva "Bang guru", asi kwete Musiki Mukuru. Uyezve, dzidziso yepanyama kusarudzwa anotsanangura muchidimbu achiita kukura zvipenyu kubva nyore kuti zvakaoma. Vasunungurwe joko dzechitendero dzidziso uye kuvimba nesayenzi European, ungangotarisa mhinduro yomubvunzo wokuti kana Mwari ariko akaipa. Chitendero rava zvetsika chakajairika uye hapana zvakawanda. Asi nzara - zvakanakisisa hwokuti mvura - iri. Uye kana mweya yedu inosuwa husingaperi, saka zvichida pane ichi mumwe nyika. Kutenda muna Mwari - asi, ndiko tsika chinodiwa chisingazivi kuratidza.