"Ndiani asina nesu anorwa nesu!" - Ndiani akati? Kwakatangira rokuti

Imwe yakakurumbira dzikabata okuti, izvo kudziviswa kuva mazwi uye rava sirogani, chokwadi, ane kare. Pana Misangano mikuru uye zvemarudzi ose isina mhinduro nharo zvinogona kunzwika dananai chikumbiro: "! Ndiani tisinaiye anopesana isu", Uye isu anoshandiswa kuitira kuti kunzwa mashoko acho kuti haazvirangariri kungofanana achabatira unyanzvi. Zvisinei, izvozvo hazvina chokuita zvirevo uye mashoko. Nhoroondo aya mamwe nekukudza nepfungwa akanatswa.

Biblical mavambo mitsara

Vanhu vane imwe kuongorora pfungwa, vangafarira akati mutsara uyu uye nei zvakadaro vakapararira munyika. Kupindirana kwemuvanzrira wezvirevo nemabviro analogues ino mashoko ari mumitauro yakawanda, saka unogona kutaura pamusoro yose mukurumbira. Pakutanga, mashoko aya akaridza zvakasiyana, uye kunyange ratakanzwa zvose shanduro - uye anokosha uye zvichishandurwa - zvakawanda pevara ichi: "Ndiani tisinaiye anorwa nesu." Munyori aifunga chete nokuda kwangu, pasina pakukoka kukosha chii chakataurwa pamusoro vemunharaunda.

Verenga chepakutanga shanduro anogona kuva muEvhangeri yaMateu, chitsauko 12, ndima 30. Jesu akati: "Ani naani asiri kudivi rangu anorwa neni; uye asingaunganidzi pamwe chete neni anoparadzira. " Izvi zvinoreva kuti aifunga, kuti vanhu vose, kwete pakarepo kutenda, ndivo vavengi vake?

Tsanangudzo yacho hove Mutsara nemunyori

Zvechokwadi, hazvibviri kuti kubvunzurudza Jesu uye kujekesa zvaaireva. Kazhinji mashoko okuti "iye haasi anesu anorwa isu" rinoshandiswa kureva "kugara pachigaro pakachengeteka ichimirira hakushandi, kwavakarerekera hakuwaniki, munofunga kuti kwazvakarerekera, asi muri vavengi vedu." Zvisinei, kana ukanyatsoongorora Bhaibheri nyaya, uko mashoko acho anoreva hwakataurwa naJesu, mumwe anogona kuwana uyewo mashoko, yakanyorerwa vadzidzi, "Musamudzivisa, uyo asiri ndewedu iwe." Sei munhu anogona kudzidudzira duality ichi, nokuti sokuti munyori rokuti zviri vachipikisa pachake?

Jesu angave aifunga yakaoma chaizvo uye vakatenda chaizvo kuti kuna Mwari uye ushamwari kuvadzidzi vake - vari zvinhu zviviri zvakasiyana, uye kuna Mwari anotungamirira migwagwa yakawanda. Somugumisiro, chepakutanga rokuti haana kukuru sezvo pashure zvakawanda dudziro ano.

Kushandisa Bhaibheri anoparadzirwa zvinotaurwa nevezvematongerwe

Sei mutsara uyu ane simba zvakadaro, hazvishamisi dzakawanda okunyanyisa kufamba nomoyo wose nomusoro mashoko okuti "iye haasi anesu anorwa isu"? The Bible zvinoiswa kuti chiremera chokwadi, nokuti nhoroondo yacho European mafungiro. Mubvunzo simba, iyo, mukutaura kwake, anochinja, anopa kurema nenharo.

Mushure kwokukunda kufora chiKristu muEurope akashandisa Bhaibheri seinokonzera kururamiswa kwerinenge chinhu. Kutenda zvechokwadi chombo simba, uye zvakanga zvakaoma chaizvo kuwana vanhu akamboda nharo nemashoko ebhuku, rakafuridzirwa naMwari pachake. Zvisinei, izvi hazvirevi kuti iye pachake anofanira kuva mutendi.

Vladimir Lenin naMax Stirner?

Kakawanda kuratidzwa aitwa Vladimir Ulyanov, nani aizivikanwa Lenin - Pfungwa mutungamiri October Revolution yeRussian Empire pakutanga rokupedzisira remakore. The addressee aiva veboka Social Democrats vasina kutsigira pfungwa yokuti echimurenga kupambwa simba. Hazvishamisi, mashoko ambotaurwa sezvariri vakatutirana mwoyo. Nei mashoko okuti "iye haasi anesu anorwa isu" muchiLatin rinonzwika zvikuru chaizvo? Qui zvisiri Est nobiscum, adversus nos Est ...

Zvichida Lenin chose yakawanda kudzidza mabasa muzivi uye anarchist Max Stirner. Zvinonzi ndiye vakanyora dudziro iyi ebhaibheri. Zvazvinosarira kuziva vakati kutanga, asi zvose yakareruka: Stirner akafa muna 1856, apo Lenin akaberekwa chete muna 1870.

Natural Kuparadzirwa kwemashoko

zvakajeka Hlostkaya uye capacious mutsara pfungwa pfungwa huru uye kumanikidza vadzidzi kutora "rworudyi" divi. Zvichida zvakanga zvakakwana kutendeukira okuti "iye haasi anesu anorwa nesu" nenzira chaiyo Bolshevik sirogani. Masirogani zvakanaka midzi vadanana nevazhinji kusadzidza pamusoro proletariat, asi mubhaibheri kwakabva mashoko vakurukuri havadi. Kunyange, Ungangove vanongotevera havazivi Bhaibheri akadai akadzama kuti tiite zvimwe zvakafanana.

Muedzo kushandisa akakodzera okuti, kunotsigirwa kare kare, kubvira nguva nenguva anopepuka mu vakurukuri siyana, asi izvozvo zvinoita zvikuru zvikuru. Hazvishamisi kuti pamazuva edu mutsara anoonekwa somunhu nechisimba uye asingabvumi kuchinja.

Kukodzera of mutongo ane mupfungwa yakasiyana nechimiro chokureva

sei munhu ari kupisa kutaura nomwoyo wose Anovhiringidza okuti "iye haasi anesu anorwa isu"? Zvino aya anogona chete tariro Anotadzira pfungwa, uye pachinzvimbo nevatsigiri, izvo anotarisira kugamuchira wezvematongerwe enyika nenzira iyi, iye achagamuchira yakawanda norupi.

Contemporary muvanhu European anoedza kuomerera mutemo wokubvumira, ichipa vanhu vane navanopinda chakarondedzera kodzero dzevanhu nerusununguko. Saka chii rakapinza kusiyana yakajeka pachena Zvakaipa kwakanaka unongova mumwe bhendesera mhinduro. Asi, tinofanira kubvuma kuti okunyanyisa ndezvipi mafeni ake, uye ipapo mamiriro ezvinhu enyika anotanga kudzikira.

Kazhinji nemumwe okuti ambotaurwa zvakajeka achiseka intonation - kana munhu atanga zvakare achinyatsokumbira kudzivirira mhosva yavo, achisiyanisa mapoka akasiyana evanhu uye kuratidza kukosha nezvaakatonga. Zvechokwadi, zvakaoma aifara zvakare, anonzwisisa chii anoenda kure uye anova akafanana Lenin, nhepfenyuro kubva warrior motokari nezvokudiwa wenyika chimurenga, sezvo voltage anodonhedza. Chokwadi, ichi rinoshanda chete kuti vanhu dzakakodzera vanogona nemazvo kuongorora mafungiro dzevateereri kuchinja mirayiridzo kutaura.

Zvino tava yakashongedzwa okunyanyisa masirogani dzakadaro, kashoma ainyepa, saka speechwriters vanoedza kuva pakati nepakati wenyaya, izvo haabvumirwi yakakanganiswa kana zvakawanda kududzira, uye (kana zvichibvira) hakusi kukuru zvinotaurwa nevezvematongerwe uye categorical chikumbiro.